Melissa Gouty
Jan 23, 2024

--

Hi, Chris!

I agree that any author would write a piece differently decades after the original, but does that mean that someone else has the right to change the original?

Yes. I agree that the meaning isn't changed with these editing changes, but would it be richer if those original words had not be excised?

I would also counter with the thought that just because retro-editing hasn't happened yet in music and movies, doesn't mean it won't, especially since many movies stem from books?

Thanks for the thoughtful debate. I really appreciate it when anyone takes the time to read and respond!

--

--

Melissa Gouty
Melissa Gouty

Written by Melissa Gouty

Writer, teacher, speaker, and observer of human nature. Content for HVAC & Plumbing Businesses. Author of The Magic of Ordinary. LiteratureLust and GardenGlory.

No responses yet